Siri Mendidik Zakir Naik. 2 :
Ved Prakash’s Suggestion?
<script async src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.
com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<script>
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({
google_ad_client: "ca-pub-2960278825814307",
enable_page_level_ads: true
});
</script>
Question.
Did Dr. Ved Prakash advises all Hindus to
convert to Islam?
Answer.
No. Dr. Ved Prakash never suggested that because
most probably this person doesn't exist.. Only
propaganda groups like Zakir and his followers try
to mislead the public, especially Hindus because
of their own agenda. There is not a single word
about the Prophet in any of the Hindu Scriptures
except in the name of the phonetic sound only. But
it refers to other negative elements. All of the words
used by Ved Prakash are merely literal or transliteral
but their original meaning is something else. His
original purpose was to find common ground with the
aim of bringing about religious harmony. No news
about Ved Prakash, never changed his religion but
if he changes his religion, he would lose the right to
evaluate Hinduism.
Manipulations.
Recently this photo circulated in whatsapp / Fb.
This viraled photo was used in a seminar program. It seems
to suggest that Hindus convert to Islam by propagandist. But
in reality, this statement has been manipulated by a number
of people for their own agenda.
Who is Dr. Ved Prakash?
The identity of Dr Ved Prakash Upaddhay is very vague. No
data can be authenticated. It is as if this character was
designed for propaganda purposes, was associated with
several other persons with the name Ved Prakash. Dr Ved
Prakash Upaddhay never made a live video to prove his new
theory or his existence. Only he or his immediate family can
prove the validity of his existence.
Dr Ved Prakash Upaddhay or Waid Barkash (Muslim writers
used the name) is said to be the person came up with the
book on idea of Kalki avatar is the prophet. A Professor at
Allahabad University, specializing in Sanskrit. His father's
name is Ram Sajiwan Sumitradevi and his mother is Pratima
Devi Tripathi. Looking at his name, it doesn't seem to have
any connection at all because his surname is so different.
Whereas her father's name was as if the woman's name
was written on the back. Both of her parents' names have
no explicit reference. He is also listed on Marquis Who's Who
as a 'noteworthy educator', when referenced in the list it was
found that the person’s real name was Ved Prakash NANDA
of Denver, United States lawyer rather than Ved Prakash
Upaddhay. While Dr Ved Prakash is said to have received
the Nilakantha Daibagna award from the Center for Astrological
Study & Research, 1998. But references indicate that the
award was received by another astrologer by the name of
Ved Prakash, we can refer to it on YouTube. There is a lot
of discrepancies in the profile of so called Dr. Ved Prakash
expressed by the propagandists.
Idoelogy of Ved Prakash.
Ved Prakash buys the belief of some Ahmadiyah Muslims
in India who believes Kalki avatara, and Imam Mahadi.
Their founder Ahmadiyah Sect, Mirza Ahmad Ghulam
considered as Kalki avatar.
Did he really openly said ‘all Hindus to convert to Islam’?
If Ved Prakash openly declared that all Hindu must convert
to Islam, then why he and his family never converted in the
first place? How is he contradicting with his own words?
Can anyone quote the reference page number which
proves from the original book in Hindi?
Dr. Ved Prakash Never Converted Out. Does not
Represent Hinduism.
He never converted because he never said so.(If he
changed his religion, he would lose the right to
speak about Hinduism.) He is an Arya Samaj follower
whom only accept God in nirguna form, which are
compromises the Islamic way of thinking. Arya Samaj
does not represent Hinduism. Followers of Arya Samaj
are just a small branch of Jnana Yoga, one of the four
streams (Raja Yoga, Jnana Yoga, Bhakti Yoga and
Karma Yoga) of Hinduism. Dr Ved Prakash's opinion
does not represent the entire Hindu religion. The book
titled 'Kalki Autar Aur Mohamad Sahib ' in 1969,
originally written in Hindi, later translated into Bengali
by Ashit Kumar Bandhopaddhay and later to English
by Muhammad Alamgir. The original book is not
detectable or does not exist. The book was written
based on the articles of Acharya Maulana Usmani
and Vidyarti Abdul Haq of Ahmadiyah followers who
try to portray Mirza Ghulam Ahmad as the Kalki
Avatar later associated with Prophet.
The book was written with the intention to bring
harmony between Ahmadiyah Muslims and Hindus
in order to live peacefully because some of the
Ahmadiyahs believe Kalki Avatar. Some later
writers then made their own assumptions about
the book and came up with suggestions and try
to infuse it to the Hindus.
Some of the Ahmadis such Vidyayarti Abdul Haq
wrote about Prophet in Hindu scriptures in 1937.
Beside that, Acharya Maulana Syed Naved Usmani
wrote in 1940. So, Ved Prakash tried to show
similarity between Kalki avatar and Prophet
based to earlier writers.
Cross Checking.
Some cross checkings on the claims, there is
no real proof to claim. There are more contractions
and all the claims were speculations and biased
arguments. It were the Muslim propagandists
came up with such notion above to confuse and
attempt to convert Hindus. Many of Muslim writers
used the book as propaganda tool and came up
with articles and books to support the claim further.
The original book were translated and published
Moulana Ghulam Nabi Shah Naqshbandi, and editor
Syed Mohd Abdul Qadeer Azm in English. And s
ome religious manipulators such as Q.S. Khan,
Zakir Naik and many others manipulated the book
to maximum. Most of the quotations of Zakir in his
speech plagiarized from this book.
The assumption, Muhammad have been described
in four ways in vedas and Puranas.That are
Narashangsa (The praised one), Antim rishi ( The
final sage), Kalki Avatar ( The Sage of last period)
and Muhamad mentioned by names in Veda.
Therefore, from all four, it is Muhamad who is
pointed out. But when checked in Kalki Purana,
main text about Kalki Avatar, there are many
contradictions including the worst is, if we accept
Kalki is the last prophet of Islam, then all other
avatars should be some earlier Prohphets of Islam.
If so, then how about Varaha Avatar? Do Muslims
will accept Varaha Avatar is also as a former Muslim
Prophet? For your information, Varaha Avatar is
swine/pig form.
Whereas according to the Kalki Purana, Kalki has
2 wives only and the Prophet has many wives.
Kalki's parents lived to an old age while the Prophet
was orphaned. The Avatar had 3 brothers and the
Prophet had no brothers. The Avatar had 4 sons
while the Prophet has no son.
Kalki is Avatara (the descendant) that God will
come to earth to help his people when needs
such as adharma have been preached, while
the Prophet is the messenger of God chosen
among men. In addition, Kalki received the horse
(Devadatta) used throughout his life, gets a sword
and a parrot (Suka) bird from Mahadeva (Shiva),
using it until the last day while the Prophet has no
such gift except the buraq used during Israq Mikraj.
Kalki learned the Vedas and art of fight from
Parasurama while the Prophet received the messenger
through angels. Kalki also has magical powers like
Ashta Siddhis while the Prophet does not.
Conclusion.
There are many differences that can be listed if
studied in depth in Hindu scriptures. Why there
is no single word mentioned in Islamic scriptures
about Kalki since it is last scripture and about
last prophet?.
There is not one word about Prophet Muhammad
in any of the Hindu scriptures. All of these "arguments"
are mere assumptions. The suggestions in the picture
are false, lie, slanderous, and blasphemy towards
Hinduism and Hindu scriptures. Hope the responsible
party to stop this terrible act. If the author of the book
exists, then he should come forward with the original
book showing the recommendation to prove the
truth of his words. Until then it is another propaganda
of conversion agents.
Om Namasivaya.
Sivasiddhi.
Sivasiddhi Spiritual Foundation.
29 September 2019
Bahasa Malaysia Version.
Reference
2.Danial Zainal Abidin,Islam the Misunderstood Religion,
PTS Millennia Sdn Bhd ,2012 pg 93/ 94
3.4 Soalan Yang Membongkar Pembohongan Dan
Kebodohan Zakir
Kebodohan Zakir
4. Bhumipati Das, Kalki Purana (Translated).
Jai Nitai Press 2006, India
5.Muslim blogger.
6.Upaddhay, Ved Prakash, Muhammad in Hindu Scriptures
(Translated), (2006) Delhi: Islamic Book Service, India
8.Dr Ved Prakash Phd Astrology
9. Dr Ved Prakash Upaddhay
10. Ved Prakash Nanda.
11.Dilema Muslim
12.Zakir’s modus operandi on religion conversion
13.Kepada Orang Yang Mempertuhankan Zakir
14.An Open Letter to Dr.Zakir Naik: Hindus are Demanding
a Public Apology from Zakir Naik
No comments:
Post a Comment